Once Van figures out what the girls are up to, he offers the tickets to the girl with the best tits. Kiley lets Van feel up her boobs, and after a brief hesitation she joins Carolina in sucking and stroking her stepbrother in a double blowjob. Carolina takes her time undressing herself and Kiley and then escalates things further by suggesting that they fuck Van.
Kiley wants the ticket badly enough to agree, and it's not long before the girls are taking turns riding Van's face and stiffie. When they have each gotten off, they work together once again to bring Van to climax until he hits Carolina's face with his cumshot. Only then does he reveal that the extra ticket is for his friend, meaning that all of their efforts were for nothing.